Meeting Minutes for October 12, 2026
Renaissance Community Development District
The Regular Meeting of the Board of Supervisors of the Renaissance Community Development District was held on Monday, October 12, 2026 at 9:00 a.m. at Cole, Scott & Kissane, 5220 Summerlin Commons Blvd., Suite 201A, Fort Myers, FL and via web conference.
Present and constituting a quorum were:
Linda Stuart – Vice Chair
Chris Bezaire – Assistant Secretary
Steve Epkins – Assistant Secretary
George Pattee – Assistant Secretary
Supervisors attending remotely:
Doug Dickey – Chair
Also present were:
Melissa Gindling – District Manager, Premier District Management (PDM)
Len Tosto – (PDM)
Robert Eichelberger – Associate General Counsel, Cole, Scott & Kissane
Paul Halverson – Resident
Mark Harper – Resident
Attending remotely were:
Chris Pepin – Field Manager, Community Field Services
Jessica Cribbett – Project Administrator, CE-Site
Michael Miller
Savannah
Hector Perez – DTA Public Finance
FIRST ORDER OF BUSINESS Call to Order and Roll Call
The Renaissance Community Development District meeting was called to order at 9:00 a.m., and District Manager Melissa Gindling called the roll. Vice Chair Stuart, Supervisors Bezaire, Epkins and Pattee were present with Chair Dickey joining online. Also in attendance were District Manager Melissa Gindling, Len Tosto from PDM, Robert Eichelberger Associate General Counsel, and residents Paul Halverson and Mark Harper. Joining online were Field Manager Chris Pepin, Jessica Cribbett from CE-Site, Savannah and Michael Miller.
On MOTION by Vice Chair Stuart, seconded by Supervisor Pattee, with all in favor, the Board approved the remote participation of Chair Dickey.
SECOND ORDER OF BUSINESS Approval of the Agenda
The Board approved the agenda as presented.
On MOTION by Supervisor Epkins, seconded by Vice Chair Stuart, with all in favor the Board approved the agenda as presented.
THIRD ORDER OF BUSINESS Audience Comments on Agenda Items
There were no audience comments.
FOURTH ORDER OF BUSINESS Consent Agenda
A. Items to be Pulled for Discussion
B. Motion to Approve Consent Items
On MOTION by Supervisor Pattee, seconded by Supervisor Bezaire, with all in favor, the Board approved all consent items.
C. Consideration of Items Pulled for Discussion
D. Consent Items
i. Draft Regular Meeting Minutes for September 14, 2026
ii. Financial Report for September 2026
iii. Project Tracking Log
iv. Repairs and Expenses Tracking Log
v. FY 2026 Goals and Objectives Report Card
FIFTH ORDER OF BUSINESS Old Business
A. Lakes 10 and 18 Shoreline Restoration Follow-up
i. Contract Negotiation Follow-up
Attorney Eichelberger reported that a revised contract had been drafted for the Board to review prior to being submitted to Talon. He reviewed the proposed revisions to the original proposal, including the establishment of firm pricing, a requirement for downward price adjustments for any work not performed, conditioning the 33% mobilization payment upon the completion of defined performance requirements, mandatory written change orders prior to any additional work being undertaken, enhanced environmental and erosion control incident reporting requirements, a one year workmanship warranty, and inclusion of sovereign immunity provisions.
Vice Chair Stuart asked whether the proposed contract revisions were typical for this type of agreement. Attorney Eichelberger advised that the provisions were standard contractual protections for the District and did not anticipate significant resistance from the contractor.
Following discussion of the recommended revisions, the Board expressed support for the proposed changes and had no objection to the contract being forwarded to Talon for review. Supervisor Pattee was appointed to assist Attorney Eichelberger with any necessary contract negotiations to facilitate timely execution of the agreement.
ii. Staging and Access Areas
District Manager Gindling reported that Talon conducted a site visit and provided several access options for consideration, which were included in the meeting handouts. Field Manager Pepin reviewed the proposed access areas for Lakes 10 and 18, noting that approximately 9 to 10 feet of access width would be required. He further explained that Clusia bushes would need to be removed at the Lake 18 access point and that some landscaping would need to be removed at the Lake 10 access point.
The Board requested that the contractor make every effort to keep the golf cart path accessible during construction. It was noted that some of the bushes may be located on golf course property and that resident George Trilleli reportedly paid for the installation and annual trimming of certain landscaping features. Staff was directed to coordinate with the resident and obtain permission for the removal and replacement of any affected landscaping.
The Board also requested clarification on whether Talon’s scope includes replacement of landscaping in addition to sod restoration, or whether such work would constitute an additional cost. Staff indicated that this question would be reviewed with the contractor and District counsel.
iii. Construction Schedule and Notifications
Field Manager Pepin reported that Talon expects to begin the shoreline restoration project in December or January, depending on lake levels. Work would start at Lake 18 and is expected to take three to four weeks, followed by approximately one week for sod installation and restoration of the access areas. The contractor would then move to Lake 10 under a similar schedule. The proposed construction timeline will be incorporated into the contract.
B. SFWMD Notice of Noncompliance Update
District Manager Gindling reported that a second non-compliance letter was received from the South Florida Water Management District noting that Old World Climbing Fern and Melaleuca remained in a portion of the large preserve. Field Manager Pepin immediately notified the preserve management contractor, who completed an additional treatment and follow-up treatments. SFWMD was advised of the corrective actions taken.
Field Manager Pepin noted that it may be appropriate to increase preserve maintenance from an annual to a semi-annual schedule. It was clarified that the on-site preserve, where the issues were identified, is currently serviced only once per year. Following discussion, the Board directed staff to obtain proposals for treating the on-site preserve two and three times annually for cost comparison purposes.
C. RCA Request for Parking Spots for Guardhouse Employees
Mr. Halverson commented that the RCA is getting pricing for this project, and that Attorney Williams will begin drafting a document for the project once further plans are in place.
D. Upcoming Board Vacancies
i. Letter of Interest from Mark Harper
District Manager Gindling reported that two letters of interest had been received for the upcoming Board vacancies, including one from Mr. Harper.
Supervisor Pattee commented that Mr. Harper possesses a strong professional background and emphasized the Board’s desire to appoint an engaged individual with the skills, knowledge, and commitment to help improve the Renaissance community. Mr. Harper expressed his interest in serving the District and stated that learning about the CDD has been both informative and rewarding.
The Board advised that Paul Halverson would need to submit a letter of interest if he wished to be considered for appointment to the Board.
The Board discussed potential timelines for Board transitions and appointments and agreed to continue the discussion at the November meeting.
E. Discussion on New O&M Assessment Methodology
Hector Perez joined the meeting remotely at 9:47 a.m.
i. DTA Public Finance Proposal Follow-up – Hector Perez at 9:30 a.m.
Mr. Perez provided an overview of DTA Public Finance and its experience with assessment methodologies, impact fee studies, and special district financing. He explained that methodologies must be supported by objective calculations and transparent data and noted the firm’s familiarity with entities in Florida. He stated that DTA had reviewed the materials provided by District Manager Gindling and was confident it could assist the District in developing an appropriate methodology. He also expressed interest in visiting the community.
Mr. Perez advised that, if selected, DTA would require approximately three to four months to complete the study. District Manager Gindling noted that the report would need to be completed by May 2027 to align with the FY 2028 budget process.
Staff was directed to coordinate the follow-up discussion, explore scheduling a site visit, and request a revised proposal for consideration at the November meeting. District Manager Gindling was also directed to update the project timeline to reflect key FY 2028 budget deadlines.
F. Insurance Renewal Update
District Manager Gindling reviewed the District’s insurance renewal options and reported that the Brown & Brown/Preferred proposal was selected, including property, cyber, crime, general liability, and public officials liability coverage.
Mr. Halverson inquired about liability protections. The Board directed Attorney Williams to follow up with Mr. Halverson on the matter.
Chair Dickey had executed the insurance binder between meetings, and the Board ratified the insurance renewal.
On MOTION by Supervisor Pattee, seconded by Vice Chair Stuart, with all in favor, the Board ratified the new policy from Brown u0026amp; Brown/Preferred.
SIXTH ORDER OF BUSINESS New Business
A. Estimate for Grading Repairs at 12450 Vittoria Way
Field Manager Pepin reported that the original request was to regrade, smooth, and sod the area behind 12450 Vittoria Way where a former plant bed had been located. While reviewing the site, Pristine Lakes and Wetlands also identified several shoreline washouts and drainage concerns, and obtained pricing for additional repairs, including drain boxes and erosion repairs at nearby locations.
Chair Dickey questioned whether repairs related to drainage originating from private property should be the responsibility of the affected homeowners. The Board discussed erosion concerns near 12711 and 12720 Vittoria Way, noting that the issue at 12711 may be associated with conditions on private property, while the concern at 12720 appeared to be associated with a soft spot along the berm.
Resident Mr. Halverson commented that he had previously inspected the area and found no evidence of an irrigation line failure. In his opinion, the erosion was not caused by irrigation and would be better addressed through the installation of a catch basin to improve drainage.
Following discussion, the Board concurred that any repairs necessary to address drainage originating from private property should be the responsibility of the affected homeowners. The Board expressed support for requiring homeowners to bear the cost of any catch basin improvements determined to be necessary due to private drainage conditions.
Field Manager Pepin was directed to obtain a revised proposal separating the costs associated with the affected properties and including pricing for an 18-inch catch basin.
District Manager Gindling was directed to provide correspondence to the affected homeowners outlining the proposed repairs and advising that the homeowners either complete the necessary work or reimburse the District for the cost of the repairs.
SEVENTH ORDER OF BUSINESS Field Manager’s Report
A. Field Manager’s Report
Field Manager Pepin reviewed some highlights of his field report, including:
- A recent heavy aquatic treatment resulted in significant die-off of spatterdock and other shoreline vegetation.
- Coconuts and debris were noted along the shoreline behind 9311 Vittoria Court. Mr. Halverson agreed to speak with the homeowner regarding proper disposal of palm fronds.
- A new washout was identified behind 12731 Terabella Way, apparently caused by runoff from a pool drain.
- Brazilian pepper, climbing cassia, and balsam apple were beginning to emerge in several areas, and staff intends to monitor and treat these invasive species.
- Balsam apple vine was observed growing on sections of the perimeter fence and is scheduled for treatment.
- Debris, including pine needles, coconuts, and palm fronds, was cleared from stormwater management structures.
- A log was observed near the overflow structure in Lake 01; the lake maintenance contractor was directed to remove it to prevent potential blockage.
- Water quality in Lake 02 continues to be affected by submerged weeds and remaining spatterdock, but conditions are expected to improve following additional treatments.
The Board asked staff to send a letter to 9311 Vittoria Ct regarding the coconuts along the shoreline, as well as send letters to the residents regarding recent washouts that were noted during this inspection.
The Board also requested confirmation as to whether the Humberts had previously received correspondence regarding their washout concern, with District Manager Gindling to determine if additional notification is warranted.
B. Follow-up Items
No additional items.
Supervisor Epkins left the meeting at 10:55 a.m. and returned at 10:59 a.m.
EIGHTH ORDER OF BUSINESS Attorney
A. Encroachment Agreement with 12450 Vittoria Way Update
Attorney Eichelberger reported that he has made multiple attempts to contact the resident regarding the encroachment agreement but has not received a response. He noted that the resident has already executed the agreement and that only one provision remains unresolved. Following discussion, the Board agreed to remove the item from future agendas. If the resident contacts counsel, it can me resolved outside of a meeting.
B. Letter Regarding Grass Clippings in Lakes
Attorney Williams has prepared a draft letter regarding grass clippings being discharged into the lakes, which will be distributed to residents shortly.
NINTH ORDER OF BUSINESS Engineer
Jessica Cribbett reported that she had no engineering updates at this time.
TENTH ORDER OF BUSINESS District Manager
A. Quorum Check: November 9, 2026
A quorum was confirmed for the next meeting.
District Manager Gindling reported that staff was preparing a reserve fund allocation resolution for Board consideration at the November meeting.
ELEVENTH ORDER OF BUSINESS Supervisor Requests/Comments
There were none.
TWELTH ORDER OF BUSINESS Audience Comments
There were none.